Start Learning Free

Before You Begin

Question #42934

Difficulty: 8/10 | 🟢 Free

The Question

Two identical atomic ions, each with a positive charge +Q+Q, interact via an effective interatomic potential Uint(R)U_{int}(R). In the absence of other charges, this potential has a minimum at an equilibrium separation R0R_0. For all relevant separations RR, it can be approximated as a harmonic well Uint(R)=12k(R−R0)2U_{int}(R) = \frac{1}{2}k(R-R_0)^2, where kk is the effective spring constant. Note that Uint(R)U_{int}(R) already accounts for the Coulomb repulsion between the two ions. A point charge −q-q (q>0q > 0) is placed exactly at the midpoint between the two ions. By the principle of superposition, the new total potential energy includes the electrostatic interaction between −q-q and the ions. As qq is increased, the equilibrium separation RR decreases. If qq exceeds a critical value qmaxq_{max}, the symmetric equilibrium becomes unstable and the system collapses. Find qmaxq_{max}. Assume all quantities are in standard SI units and ϵ0\epsilon_0 is the vacuum permittivity.

Options

  • A.

    4πϵ0kR0327Q\frac{4 \pi \epsilon_0 k R_0^3}{27 Q}

  • B.

    8πϵ0kR0327Q\frac{8 \pi \epsilon_0 k R_0^3}{27 Q}

  • C.

    2πϵ0kR039Q\frac{2 \pi \epsilon_0 k R_0^3}{9 Q}

  • D.

    πϵ0kR034Q\frac{\pi \epsilon_0 k R_0^3}{4 Q}

Check Your Answer

Correct Answer

Step-by-Step Solution

Explanation

How the Examiner Thinks

Multi-Concept_Bridge

Master problems that require linking physics and math concepts to solve complex competitive questions.

Concepts Behind This Question

Neutral Equilibrium Points|Interatomic Force Curve|Integration

Why This Question Is Tricky

Common Mistakes

This question tests the student's ability to analyze the stability of an equilibrium point governed by the superposition of a harmonic restoring potential and an inverse-square electrostatic potential.

A common trap is assuming that setting the first derivative of the potential energy to zero (net force = 0) is sufficient to find a valid physical state for any charge qq.

However, because the electrostatic attractive force grows as 1/R21/R^2 while the restoring force only grows linearly as (R0−R)(R_0 - R), the system possesses a critical point of instability.

Students must apply the second derivative test (d2UdR2>0\frac{d^2U}{dR^2} > 0) to find the threshold separation R=2R0/3R = 2R_0/3, below which the nuclei collapse into each other.

Failure to check the divergence of the force leads to the incorrect assumption that the system can sustain any arbitrary charge.

Quick Facts About This Question

Question Information

SubjectPhysics
ChapterElectric Charges and Fields - Class 12
ConceptNeutral Equilibrium Points
Difficulty8
Cognitive Load7
Target Solve Time160 sec
AccessFree